EA Sports activities FC 24 Assessment: FIFA’s Promised Rebirth Stays a Rehash


At this level, FIFA, EA’s long-running and ridiculously profitable sports activities online game franchise, is probably simply as huge as soccer itself. In truth, FIFA video games are inseparable from the game; spoken of collectively, complementing one another, and influencing and informing one another as each the online game and the game proceed to vary and churn. EA Sports activities FIFA can be deeply tied with soccer tradition. Individuals who watch soccer, play FIFA. Heck, skilled footballers play FIFA. Elite gamers who make it to the duvet of a FIFA recreation think about it as a profession achievement. Soccer entities are invested within the franchise, which wields the irreplicable advertising energy to convey footballers, leagues, soccer golf equipment and competitions to a really international viewers. It’s a mutual, symbiotic relationship between the largest sport on the planet and the largest sports activities online game franchise on the planet, the place the stability of energy and trade of id constantly shift. One factor is obvious, that each have been extremely and immeasurably instrumental in one another’s successes, preserving one another fed and fats.

This extremely profitable and worthwhile 30-year partnership, that started with FIFA Worldwide Soccer in 1993, modified final 12 months when EA and Fédération Internationale de Soccer Affiliation (FIFA), the worldwide soccer administrative physique that governs the attractive recreation and lends its title to the online game franchise, terminated their licensing settlement. This meant that EA Sports activities’ soccer video video games might not be referred to as FIFA, a globally recognised model title that the collection had virtually change into synonymous with. Think about, if McDonald’s might not name their eating places McDonald’s, or if Coca Cola began botting their beverage underneath a brand new moniker. To name it only a change could be an understatement; it’s a rebirth. After promoting over 325 million copies, the FIFA collection ended final 12 months with FIFA 23, but it surely didn’t go away. Birthed within the mandate of EA Sports activities’ annual launch cycle and promising a brand new starting, EA Sports activities FC 24 has arrived rather than what would have been FIFA 24.

Mortal Kombat 1 Assessment: New Flesh on Previous Bones

Through the years, the FIFA collection has confronted scattered criticism over its iterative releases, with each new title that includes minor upgrades and simply sufficient new stuff that may lure devoted gamers into shopping for their new recreation. In truth, EA actively coerces gamers to shell out for a brand new FIFA launch yearly by halting updates on the earlier title and erasing all person progress on its wildly in style and ethically grey Final Crew (FUT) recreation mode, the place gamers are inspired to spend real-life cash to purchase costly participant packs and bundles that may in any other case take countless hours of grind to acquire by regular gameplay.

Regardless of how a lot you spent on assembling your FUT membership within the final recreation, each new FIFA title hits the reset button, making you begin from the scratch and spend extra. For those who have been apprehensive (or hoping) that the collection would try and chart a brand new course or rewrite its playbook with EA Sports activities FC 24, you would be happy (or dissatisfied) to know that EA’s latest soccer fantasia very a lot maintains the established order. FC 24 is extra fascinated about rehashing than rewriting, ensuring that its legion of gamers, who’ve come to count on the FIFA expertise they get annually, don’t discover themselves in unfamiliar floor with an upended strategy.

Regardless of, the collection’ reluctance to reinvent itself, it might be a tad unfair to say that FC 24 is totally different solely in title. There are modifications right here, a few of them representing an enchancment over FIFA 23, however none of them substantial sufficient to underscore a contemporary expertise. The primary, and maybe the best of them, is within the recreation’s essential menu itself. Gone is that cumbersome (and admittedly aesthetically ugly and mechanically psychopathic) horizontally-aligned menu that had been overstaying its welcome for the previous few editions. As an alternative, we get a cleaner, sharper and a traditional horizontal menu that lists all of FC 24’s modes on provide, with essentially the most not too long ago performed mode dynamically climbing up high.

fc24 1 fc 24

The vertical menu is appreciated
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

An total cleaner, newer presentation pervades EA Sports activities’ new soccer recreation, too. This is applicable to in-game cutscene packages in the beginning and finish of a match and at half-time, all of which attempt to be a better illustration of real-life broadcasts. You see grounds males tending to the pitch earlier than kick-off, muddied gamers assembling within the dressing room for the half-time discuss from the supervisor, and pitch facet TV presenters and pundits gesticulating animatedly at full-time. There are fancy new in-game stat overlays that give visible representations of shot makes an attempt, present anticipated objectives, and win chances. You clearly get nerd-level statistics on the center and finish of the sport that element participant performances, warmth maps, and passing metrics, however these have existed in earlier editions, too.

Extra perceptible and vital modifications come to in-game participant animations. EA’s cameras file real-life match footage in stadiums and every FIFA recreation takes on intensive movement seize to translate precise participant actions into digital participant actions. These have gotten higher over time, and in FC24 participant animations are additional refined to mirror athletic efficiency. They means the physique of participant twists whereas taking part in a slender angle go, the best way they pirouette whereas receiving a ball and altering instructions, and the best way their foot wraps across the ball so as to add curl to a cross — all of it seems lifelike and plausible, immersing you that rather more into the sport. The gameplay itself feels a bit slower, extra deliberate than earlier video games, with a bit extra deal with constructing play, as has been the pattern in latest editions. Targets can are available all kinds of the way, however you should discover the proper solution to rating in your group. Setting a transparent tactic, and bringing in the proper gamers to execute it feels vital, even when it may not be that huge an element behind the scenes.

nkunku fc24 fc 24

Improved participant animations shine whereas taking photographs or taking part in passes
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

Whereas attacking roughly feels just like FIFA 23, defending appears to have seen a number of modifications, principally for the more serious. The defensive facet of the sport simply feels totally different in virtually inexplicable methods. It’s tougher, however not in manners that really feel truthful or lifelike. It is way more tough to trace again or get better after you make a defensive error. In truth, you need not make an error to concede a aim. The opposing attacker may rapidly step in a distinct path, to depart you flat footed, and as soon as you’ve got been bluffed, you are taken out of the sequence of occasions. Right here, AI-controlled defenders don’t assist in any respect. AI gamers don’t shut within the open area, or are virtually at all times means off their designated place, thus breaking your line of defense and construction. So, in case you lose an attacker, they inevitably go on to attain.

Defensive AI points have lingered on within the collection for ages, and it is disappointing to see that they exist and, in truth, thrive in FC 24. Getting punished for a single error, and never with the ability to make recoveries feels annoying each time it occurs. It is also way more tough to defend on crosses and also you’re very doubtless going to lose an aerial battle, except you’ve gotten a towering centre again in your group. You defender’s horrible positioning when a cross comes into your field places you at a large drawback, too. And it would not assist that AI headed objectives are virtually too excellent, exact and highly effective that beat your keeper most of the time.

fc24 defence fc 24 defence

Defending crosses in FC 24 is way more tough
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

And even in case you do make the proper deal with and dispossess your opponent, there is a excessive likelihood that the ball in some way falls at one other participant’s ft within the opposing group. This has been taking place for a number of editions now, and it is no totally different in FC 24. You might make the right deal with and win the ball, solely to not win it in any respect. Usually, gamers will simply refuse to behave the best way you need them to. This occurs throughout the three areas of the pitch, however is extra obvious within the attacking third. You’d need your ahead to take the shot first time, and you will press the taking pictures enter simply earlier than they’re in regards to the obtain the ball to set off the shot. However, in some way, your striker will find yourself taking an additional contact to manage the ball after which take a shot at aim. In tight conditions, you’ve got already misplaced the window to attain as a result of your ahead determined to have a thoughts of their very own.

FC 24 additionally brings a PlayStyles function that provides real-life information from skilled footballers to their digital counterparts. These information factors manifest themselves as signature skills in gamers — a towering centre again might posses the facility header skill, whereas a cunning striker may very well be a scientific finisher. These skills are passively activated in-game in applicable conditions, handing you a bonus on the pitch. It goes a bit additional with PlayStyles+, which provides spectacular, elite skills to world class gamers. Consider Son Heung-min discovering the highest nook of the web with worldie from outdoors the field, or Erling Haaland pulling off circus acrobatics to achieve a high-hanging ball within the air. The factor is, PlayStyles — at its core — is a rehash of participant traits, which have existed in FIFA video games for a very long time. Positive, EA Sports activities has refined the mechanic and maybe added many extra information units to its complete 34 PlayStyles, it isn’t precisely as new a function as EA’s advertising group would have you ever consider.

There are some inconsistencies within the management scheme too, which didn’t exist in earlier FIFA video games. Holding down the proper bumper on the controller whereas hitting the button for grounded and lobbed passes used to execute a extra highly effective, pushed go in earlier editions. Now, these controls solely work for grounded pushed passes, and doing the identical for a lobbed go triggers a precision go mechanic. For pushed lobbed go, you now must press down each the proper and the left bumper collectively earlier than hitting the sq. button on a PlayStation controller. These are small gripes, however when grains of rice accumulate to fill a gunny sack, you begin feeling the burden.

That is to not say that taking part in a recreation of soccer on FC 24 is not enjoyable. It completely is. It at all times has been. It’s acquainted, it’s comforting, and it may be exhilarating if you pull off neat tika-taka passes, beat the opposition defenders, and slot the ball into the web. It is also simply as satisfying if you’re in a position to thwart the opposite groups assault by intelligent defensive play, win the ball, and rapidly execute transition play to mount a risk of your personal. And there is at all times other ways to play. When you’ve got a giant man up entrance, like FC 24’s cowl star Haaland, you might at all times kick it as much as your ahead and take the short path to aim. Or you might meticulously and patiently construct up play, execute the proper passes, and discover the proper second and area to tug the set off.

fc24 attack fc 24

FC 24 cowl star Erling Haaland’s skills have been faithfully recreated within the recreation
Picture Credit score: Digital Arts

The FIFA expertise modifications individual to individual from the skin, too. I do know buddies who solely play the Final Crew mode, sinking in lots of of hours to deck out their membership with huge title stars. Then, there are a lot of who simply follow on-line Seasons, selecting real-life golf equipment and taking over different gamers on-line with escalating ranges of talent as they progress by divisions. However I’ve at all times discovered the net expertise on soccer video games exasperating. You are hit with a bunch of loading screens earlier than you are truly on the pitch, and also you typically encounter idiots on-line, who preserve pausing the sport to your annoyance.

Whereas I dabble in Seasons and FUT, my ft are firmly planted within the Profession mode. I have been a Profession mode connoisseur for nearly twenty years now, and as somebody who prefers the long-haul intricacies of embarking on full-blown season with a membership as a supervisor, I have been left dissatisfied by EA sports activities’ strategy to the mode lately. Profession mode has been left to rot in neglect, barely that includes any new concepts in years. To its credit score, FC 24 makes an attempt to convey a number of modifications, however largely sticks to the tried and examined components.

If you begin a supervisor profession, now you can set an overarching philosophy in your group. You might play high-risk, high-reward Gegenpressing, or park the bus; you might mould your group right into a counter-attacking facet, or have them maintain on the ball and tiki taka their solution to glory. You may even rent coaches in keeping with your tactical imaginative and prescient that will help you execute you intend on the pitch. Scouting system adapts to those modifications, too. Your scouts can discover younger gamers who’d be the right match for the type of soccer you play. Equally, you’d profit from transferring in gamers who’d suit your philosophy. Whereas these modifications are a pleasant contact and convey one thing new to the desk, the remainder of profession mode stays largely the identical. Truthfully, there’s not a lot flawed with it, so one might argue why repair it if it is not damaged.

tactics fc 24 fc 24 tactics

Now you can set an overarching tactical imaginative and prescient in your membership in Profession mode
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

However that can’t change into an excuse to not experiment in any respect. All good formulation finally get stale, and FIFA’s profession mode hasn’t felt contemporary in about three years. Soccer as a sport has modified a lot in that point, and it feels ridiculous that EA Sports activities’ soccer video games refuse to do the identical. Why has the switch market expertise remained precisely the identical up to now few years? Why can we nonetheless have unvoiced and clunky cutscenes for negotiations and press conferences? Why hasn’t EA Sports activities carried out a Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system within the recreation, which has now change into an inextricable a part of the game? These questions have been ignored in earlier editions, and stay unanswered in FC 24.

If Profession mode feels just like the not-so-distant cousin of its older iterations, FC 24’s on-line modes really feel just like the twins of their variations from older video games. Final Crew brings little that is new to the desk, sticking to the components that rakes within the cash for EA, with the mode shoving microtransaction-based bundles and participant packs in your face at each given second. It is enjoyable at first to assemble an honest group and tackle on-line gamers, but it surely wears off fast if you realise that your opponents are lining up with a number of the greatest gamers on the planet. For those who do not spend your cash (or grind endlessly) and get the identical gamers, you are at a substantial drawback, even when the folks controlling these tremendous groups are horrible at FIFA.

Volta, the road soccer mode launched in FIFA 20, returns with the acquainted arcade 3v3, 4v4 or 5v5 expertise, making an attempt onerous to be the hip model of Futsal to attraction to a Gen Z viewers. On-line Friendlies permits you to take in your buddies in a league-style format, whereas Seasons and Co-op Seasons match you and your mates up with different on-line gamers. The PlayStation model of the sport (which I performed for the evaluate) additionally contains PlayStation Tournaments, permitting you to participate in platform-specific competitions in opposition to different gamers in E-sports-style tourneys, with prizes and pleasure at stake.

fc24 fut fc 24 fut

Final Crew returns with an aggressive microtransactions push
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

On the visible entrance, you will discover it very tough to differentiate between FC 24 and FIFA 23 when you’re on the pitch. All the things seems quite a bit prefer it seemed final 12 months. Participant likenesses enhance annually incrementally, however that at all times occurs at an imperceptible charge, by no means taking a giant leap in constancy. Whereas most main gamers have their likenesses within the recreation, massive a part of the roster, even in main groups, is made up of generic faces customised to be as near actual as they are often. In my profession mode with Premier League facet Brighton & Hove Albion, one in every of my star gamers, Kaoru Mitoma, who was top-of-the-line forwards within the league final 12 months, didn’t have his likeness reproduced within the recreation. And my supervisor, Roberto De Zerbi resembled a middle-aged rockstar on the decline, with the generic face sporting a pretend hawk.

What’s worse is that pitches look worse than earlier than. I do not know if it is the color calibration on my TV, however the grass in FC 24 stadiums at all times look oversaturated, by no means fairly nailing the pure look of a soccer floor. Stadium and crowd element, nevertheless, has improved, however if you’re taking part in a soccer recreation, you are taking a look at grass more often than not. FC 24 additionally retains the collection’ trademark janky participant animations and gestures whereas celebrating objectives. There may be particular enchancment right here, however you will typically discover them veering into uncanny valley.

fc24 faces fc 24 faces

Participant likenesses see a leap intimately in FC 24
Picture Credit score: Screenshot/ Manas Mitul

I have been taking part in FIFA video games for the reason that FIFA 1998 version, so I think about myself a little bit of a veteran of the collection. I’ve seen it change over time, attain some exhalating highs, and hit some disappointing lows. However EA Sports activities’ soccer collection has endured, largely due to intelligent advertising selections and a sore lack of competitors. That is to not say FIFA was by no means good, however followers of the franchise would be the first to agree that its previous few editions have set innovation apart and as an alternative banked on its in style and acquainted choices to simply do sufficient for its returning gamers. The Professional Evolution Soccer collection scored an personal aim and fizzled out of relevance, however the collection’ genuine on-pitch gameplay used to maintain EA on its toes. Now, with the market all wolfed up, EA Sports activities can afford to roll out virtually the identical recreation yearly, slap a brand new title on the field, and name it new.

FC 24 is new, however solely pores and skin deep. It brings beauty updates to the identical outdated components, whereas ignoring extra vital points on the pitch. Positive, the gameplay will get refined yearly, however a lot stays lacking within the core expertise. EA prioritises its money-spinning Final Crew mode, however stubbornly refuses to convey new concepts to the Profession mode. FC 24 even recycles the identical cutscenes for switch negotiations within the Profession mode we have seen for previous three to 4 years. When the franchise needed to transfer away from its FIFA branding, it introduced EA a uncommon alternative to convey a brand new id to the collection that is quick getting frustratingly acquainted. EA Sports activities FC 24 might have been a lot greater than what it’s — the identical dish with new dressing. It doesn’t come as a shock, although. In a quickly altering soccer panorama, the EA sports activities collection has discovered success in consistency. And in its acquainted, constant strategy, FC 24 stays  preoccupied with dribbling the ball alongside the identical strains, too scared to take a shot at aim and glory.


  • Acquainted, responsive gameplay
  • Welcome change to menu design
  • Improved participant animations
  • Alternative ways to play


  • Only a few modifications to Profession mode
  • Inconsistent defending
  • Rehashed PlayStyles
  • Lacks visible upgrades
  • Standard FIFA expertise

Ranking (out of 10): 6

EA Sports activities FC 24 launched September 29 on PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Sequence S/X, Xbox One, and Nintendo Swap.

Pricing begins at Rs. 3,499 for the Normal Version on Steam and Epic Video games Retailer for PC, and Rs. 4,499 on PlayStation Retailer for PS5 and PS4, and Xbox Retailer for Xbox Sequence S/X and Xbox One.

Affiliate hyperlinks could also be robotically generated – see our ethics assertion for particulars.


Leave a comment